You can be legally fired for almost any reason. How does employment at will work in Indiana?

Employment at will gives employers the right to fire anyone for almost any reason. It has been prevalent in Indiana and the United States since the late 19th century.

Many do not know the laws exist or fully understand them, said Amber Boyd Moorman, an Indianapolis employment attorney. Often people who believe they have been unfairly terminated turn to them for legal help.

“She [say] “Amber, this is very unfair.” And I have to go through the dialogue of ‘well they can do that’. They can do unfair things,” Moorman said. “They just aren’t allowed to have any illegal practices.”

While the law prohibits employers from firing employees for certain reasons, it is ultimately up to the former employee to account and prove their case in civil court. The American Civil Liberties Union It is estimated that at least 150,000 people are unfairly dismissed every year.

There were few reasons why an employer couldn’t fire someone as employment developed at will first across the country.

“The first major exception was the National Labor Relations Act of 1935,” said Matthew Finkin, a law professor at the University of Illinois. “You can be fired for any reason, but not if you join or support a union.”

Other exceptions followed in the decades that followed. Now, nationally, an employer cannot fire anyone based on race, ethnicity, religion, disability, veteran status, gender, sexual orientation, or any other protected class. These exceptions and a few others apply to workers in all states because they are established in federal law.

But some states go even further. For example, Indiana and most other states also have a public policy exemption. That’s part of it illegal to fire someone for refusing to break the law or report illegal activity at their company

“Indiana has very narrowly tailored exceptions to employment at will,” Indianapolis Attorney Moorman said. “If you’re a nurse or someone in this sector and you make a complaint of abuse or neglect, you could fall into it [the public policy exemption].”

Some states are said to go further than Indiana the National Conference of Diets, by including safeguards for employees who report or refuse to participate in violations of “administrative rules and regulations” or even “codes of professional ethics”.

Workers can also be protected by their employment contract if it states that they can only be fired for cause, are employed for a specific period of time, or contain other similar guarantees.

But Indiana does not recognize the “implicit treaty exemption.” some other states. This exception can protect employees from being fired without cause, for example, if a manager has given them verbal assurances that this would not happen, or if an employee handbook lists dismissal procedures that have not been followed. In Indiana if these are assurances not expressly in a contract, they don’t count.

The last major exception that some states recognize is the “contract of good faith and fair dealing”. The way the exemption works varies, but often it prohibits employers from firing someone “with bad faith or with malicious intent,” according to a Monthly Labor Review article.

It might look like an employer firing someone after making a big sale just to keep them from getting a commission from it. Or firing a long-time employee to keep them from receiving pension payments.

Indiana courts do not recognize this exception according to law firm Ogletree Deakins.

people can have employment contracts which they don’t do at will. How and why they can be dismissed in these cases is determined by the contract and the relevant laws.

How employees can protect themselves

Not all states require employers to provide a reason for termination at all. Indiana law does in some cases.

Employers must explain the reasons for the termination in a letter of termination if the dismissed employee had to submit letters of recommendation or “written applications showing qualifications or experience” in order to get the job.

Some states require the letter of termination be handed over to the dismissed employee By default. However, Indiana will only require writing if the former employee requests it.

If an employee believes their firing broke the law, it’s up to them to prove it, Moorman said.

“I usually think that when it comes to discrimination, there are people who lie. So there’s email, there’s corroborating evidence that we can get,” said Moorman, who has been a practitioner for nearly 20 years. “I’m not saying it’s not an uphill battle, but there’s just work that needs to be done.”

The process of proving a wrongful termination can be time-consuming and costly for the employee, experts say. Moorman is urging workers to help themselves going forward by keeping careful records now.

“We need to be a society – and indeed a people – that has some record of employment. That way you can be proactive if something happens to you,” she said. “So if you file a complaint with Human Resources because someone treated you unfairly … or you ask for housing and don’t get it, document all of those things.”

Moorman also recommends keeping a record of “good things” like positive performance reviews or thank-you emails from customers.

“And keep the document for yourself, don’t just keep it on the company’s computer,” she added.

Moorman said unions are an alternative to employment at will. Collective bargaining agreements generally oblige employers to prove a just cause for dismissal to an impartial arbitrator.

Join the conversation and sign up for the Indiana Two-Way. Text “Indiana” to 73224. Your comments and questions in response to our weekly text will help us find the answers you need about issues nationwide.

Alternatives to freelance employment

A few listeners wanted to know: Is there a possibility that Indiana law will shift from discretionary statutes to statutes that require employers to fire employees on valid grounds?

“As an outsider, I would be skeptical,” said University of Illinois law professor Finkin.

Finkin points to a 1991 attempt the Unified Law Commission Getting states to pass a termination of employment law that would create a “substantive right to protection from ‘reasonable cause’ dismissals.

Indiana and many other states have a history of adopting and applying versions of the ULC’s proposed laws. Indiana Legislature looks at three bills based on ULC models at the 2022 session. Two of them passed and received the Governor’s signature.

But not a single state has passed the Employment Termination Act since it was proposed.

“No other country allows employers to arbitrarily fire workers without reason. Not Japan, not Australia, not Germany,” said Finkin.

He said Puerto Rico and Montana have some similar safeguards.

“The German system is a good example. A dismissal must be socially justified. That’s the test required by law,” Finkin said. “And if you’ve been fired by your employer, you can go off the street to the labor court.”

Such systems tend to solve cases more efficiently, Finkin argues. In Germany, 60 percent of cases are resolved within three months, while cases of wrongful termination in the US can drag on for years

“Most of the industrial world recognizes that after the probationary period is over, workers have the right to be fired only for cause or just cause,” he said. “And they provide a public forum that decides the question, so there’s really very little cost to the employee.”

Many argue that moving away from free will would prevent job creation in the US, Finkin said.

“That was one of the main demands, employers will be reluctant to hire people because it’s expensive to fire them,” he said. “And the economic research that I am aware of suggests that there is no close connection or no connection. Hiring and firing is really a product of the much larger dynamics of an economy.”

And often, employees who win arbitrations in restricted jurisdictions primarily receive paybacks and/or severance payments rather than large amounts of damages.

“If [workers] Have access to union arbitration, how often do they win? And we have the data there [shows] Management wins about 60 percent of the time,” he said. “And they should not be arbitrarily fired because the contract requires them to carefully investigate these cases, and they know a union is available to take the case to arbitration.”

Some notes at will also guarantee employees the right to quit a job for any reason. In non-choice jurisdictions like Great Britain and Germany, Employees can still cancel, but may need to cancel a few weeks in advance.

The data tells us that Indiana’s very tight job market may see some major changes soon. But numbers don’t tell the whole story. Are you, your family or your company affected? Share your story with Reporter Adam at [email protected] or on Twitter @arayesIPB.